Emotion is not something we need to remove from thinking so that learning can begin. Emotion helps determine what we think about, what we notice, and what we remember. The important question is not whether emotion is involved in learning, but what the emotion is about.
A student worried about getting a poor grade is deeply engaged with something. But that something may be academic performance rather than mathematics, literature, or physics. A student fascinated by why a ball rolls down a ramp is engaging emotionally with an idea. Those are very different learning experiences.
Understanding that distinction requires looking beyond the classroom. It starts with the relationship between the brain and body, develops through our relationships with other people, and extends into the stories we use to understand ourselves and the world.
Key Takeaways
- Emotions direct attention, so what learners care about helps determine what they learn.
- Bodily feelings, social relationships, and culture shape the stories we use to interpret experience.
- Curiosity and perspective-taking help us question narratives that otherwise feel unquestionably true.
- Education should use academic knowledge to develop people, rather than treating performance as the endpoint.
Table of Contents
- Why Awe and Inspiration Are Rooted in the Body
- How Physical Feelings Become Meaningful Stories
- Culture Shapes What We Notice and Remember
- How Narratives Can Support Empathy or Dehumanization
- What We Feel About Determines What We Learn About
- What Education Can Learn From Early Childhood
- A Different Way to Demonstrate Learning
- The Goal Is the Development of the Person
- Sponsor: LMNT
Why Awe and Inspiration Are Rooted in the Body
Awe and inspiration can feel like unusually elevated emotional experiences. They involve beauty, possibility, purpose, and a sense of connection to something larger than ourselves. Yet these complex mental states draw on some of the most basic biological systems that keep us alive.
One important idea, developed in Antonio Damasio’s work and central to Dr. Mary Helen Immordino-Yang’s approach, is that the brain’s mapping and regulation of the body provide a foundation for mental experience. Representing what is happening inside and around the body helps create the conditions for feeling and consciousness.
The brain is not separate from the body, supervising it from a distance. It is a specialized organ within it. It supports increasingly complex feelings, beliefs, imaginings, and interpretations, while those mental states also influence the body.
That creates a continuous conversation:
- The body’s condition contributes to how we feel.
- Our interpretations of events shape our emotional experience.
- Those emotional and mental states alter how the body responds.
- Our changing bodily state becomes part of what we experience next.
This relationship extends beyond the individual. Stress, social relationships, immunity, and digestion are interconnected. Even the microorganisms living within us participate in the broader biological system.
From this perspective, awe is not an escape from biology. It is an extraordinary use of it. We connect basic processes involved in sustaining life to expansive interpretations of what life means. Stories help organize those interpretations into something that feels coherent and personally significant.
How Physical Feelings Become Meaningful Stories
Development gives us a particularly clear way to understand this process.
Immordino-Yang describes an interaction with her daughter, Nora, at about age two. She was sitting in the kitchen, feeling sad and absorbed in thought. Nora noticed, picked up her mother’s arm, and pressed it against her face. She offered comfort and expressed her love, then clarified that she especially loved the arm she was holding.
About two years later, Nora expressed her attachment differently. Lying in bed, she compared her love for her mother with her gratitude that daytime exists.
The attachment underlying those moments may have been quite similar. What changed remarkably was the child’s ability to conceptualize it.
At two, love was expressed through something immediate, physical, and concrete: contact with her mother’s arm. At four, she could connect that feeling to an idea. Daylight meant sunshine, play, and possibilities she valued. She could use her appreciation of one experience to explain another.
Development does not simply give us more feelings. It changes what we can make of those feelings.
Basic attachment, aversion, and motivational processes become the foundation for increasingly elaborate mental experiences. Over time, they can support beliefs, poetry, music, moral commitments, and complex interpretations of other people’s lives.
This continues across the lifespan. An older adult may notice a subtle detail in a situation that a younger person misses, not because the basic emotional machinery is entirely different, but because decades of experience have changed what stands out and what it means.
There is no need to reduce this to a fixed inventory of emotions into which every experience must fit. The useful point is that basic physiological and motivational processes can support a tremendous range of meanings. Experience helps us become more nuanced in how we interpret them.
Culture Shapes What We Notice and Remember
We do not move through the world as passive recording devices. We bring expectations, values, memories, and cultural habits to what we encounter. Those influences shape not only how we explain an experience afterward, but also what we notice in the first place.
Consider research comparing how people from Japanese and American cultural contexts describe an underwater scene containing plants, rocks, small fish, and one prominent fish.
Japanese participants tended to describe the surrounding scene and relationships among its elements. American participants tended to organize their descriptions around the prominent fish moving through the setting.
These are group-level tendencies, not rules about every individual. The important finding is that cultural experience can influence attention and subsequent memory, not merely the language people choose to describe an otherwise identical perception.
The same principle becomes even more consequential when we interpret social situations.
We bring our own histories to someone else’s expression, behavior, or story. We fit new experiences into existing expectations, or we revise those expectations when they no longer work. This resembles the developmental processes Jean Piaget described as assimilation and accommodation.
Our social nature makes this especially important. A sense of self is not built in isolation and then presented to other people. It develops through interaction, shared cultural practices, and the ways we accommodate one another mentally and physically.
We are actively interpreting the world while participating in it. That gives us enormous flexibility, but it also creates opportunities for serious error.
How Narratives Can Support Empathy or Dehumanization
The stories we construct can help us appreciate another person’s suffering. They can also make that suffering easier to dismiss.
This is one way to approach a deeply disturbing question: How can people who love their families and care about their neighbors participate in cruelty toward others?
One part of the explanation is a shift in how the other person is represented. If suffering is understood as happening to another human being, it can evoke concern. If a narrative recasts that person as vermin, a threat, or something less than human, the meaning of the same suffering changes.
Dehumanization does not require someone to lose every capacity for attachment or care. It can involve redirecting those capacities within a story that excludes certain people from consideration.
This does not excuse cruelty. It helps explain why the narratives we accept matter so much.
It also suggests that having emotions, including strong feelings of moral certainty, is not enough to ensure good judgment. We need habits that allow us to examine what those feelings are attached to.
Building a Habit of Checking Our Own Interpretations
Immordino-Yang describes the value of developing something like an internal checking system: a disposition to examine our motivations against other people’s experiences of them.
That means learning to ask questions such as:
- What assumptions am I bringing to this situation?
- What interpretation is making my response feel so obvious?
- How might someone else describe these same events?
- What historical, ethical, or social context am I leaving out?
- How do my beliefs and actions affect other people and the world that supports us?
The goal is not endless hesitation. Development includes learning when a situation calls for reconsideration and when it is reasonable to proceed.
But repeatedly encountering information that confirms an existing belief can make that belief feel increasingly self-evident. Social media can reinforce this pattern, as can educational experiences that treat knowledge as something we acquire once and then impose on every future situation.
Mental flexibility requires a different emotional disposition: curiosity about what we might be missing, willingness to tolerate uncertainty, and enough humility to revise a satisfying explanation.
Emotions help drive thinking, decision-making, relationships, and community life. That makes us responsible for examining them, not obligated to follow every impulse they produce.
What We Feel About Determines What We Learn About
The connection between emotion and learning becomes especially practical when we consider where a student’s emotional energy is directed.
If the central questions are “Will I fail?”, “Did I get the highest grade?”, or “Does this prove I am smart?”, then the student is thinking about evaluation and identity. Those concerns can dominate the experience, even when the assignment is nominally about science or mathematics.
If the central question is “Why does this happen?”, the emotional engagement is directed toward the subject itself.
A ball rolling down a ramp can become an invitation to think about motion and gravity. Connecting that observation to the moon’s orbit can open a much larger conceptual space. The learner is no longer simply trying to reproduce an answer. They are trying to understand something.
Performance and understanding are not the same target. An accountability system that concentrates emotional attention on scores may train students to manage evaluation more effectively without producing equally deep engagement with ideas.
Start With Interest, Then Put Academic Skills to Work
What about a child who dislikes mathematics? Curiosity does not eliminate the need to learn essential skills. Reading, writing, mathematics, and careful argument remain important.
The question is how those skills become meaningful.
One route is to begin with what the learner already finds compelling, then use academic skills to help them investigate it. Writing can communicate an explanation. Mathematics can reveal a pattern. Persuasive argument can help make a case. Filmmaking can tell a story that matters to the learner.
This reverses a common educational assumption. Instead of treating isolated skills as the ultimate destination, we treat them as tools that expand a person’s ability to understand and act in the world.
Immordino-Yang uses the relationship between a horse and its cart to make this distinction. The learner’s development is the driving capacity. Academic skills are valuable resources carried along in service of that development. Focusing exclusively on the contents of the cart misses the question of who is becoming capable of using them.
What Education Can Learn From Early Childhood
In early childhood settings, the importance of curiosity is often obvious. Water, sand, objects to manipulate, choices, and opportunities to interact give children ways to investigate their surroundings and build meaning.
Good early education does not merely provide stimulation. It invites children to think and expands the ways they can use their natural curiosity.
Yet later schooling can treat that same inclination as inefficient, disruptive, or difficult to control. The task becomes receiving an explanation and returning the expected answer.
When does this shift occur? There is no single age. It depends on the school, educational system, and opportunities available to the learner. Immordino-Yang argues that, for many students, it is firmly in place by adolescence.
That timing is particularly unfortunate.
Adolescence brings growing capacities and motivation to infer complex meaning. A pair of shoes may become a statement about sport, sustainability, belonging, or resistance to adult expectations. Young people increasingly want to explore identity, social relationships, ethics, and big questions about the world.
At precisely this stage, education can become more tightly focused on controlled inputs, expected outputs, and narrowly defined demonstrations of achievement.
Literature offers a useful example. Remembering a minor character’s name in Great Expectations is not the same as grappling with the book’s meaning. Factual details can support interpretation, but reproducing them is not the ultimate reason to read.
Support Agency Without Abandoning Rigor
Adults often constrain young people’s curiosity for understandable reasons. They worry about risk, distraction, and failure within the existing system.
But shielding students from the work of constructing meaning can also limit their development.
The alternative is not to remove structure or let every claim stand unchallenged. It is to provide safe, developmentally appropriate opportunities to investigate difficult questions, while helping students become more systematic and rigorous.
That includes learning to:
- Examine the assumptions behind a question.
- Consider competing explanations and perspectives.
- Reflect on decisions made during an investigation.
- Revise beliefs when the work reveals a better account.
- Remain engaged when a problem does not yield an immediate answer.
This requires substantial expertise from educators. Teachers need preparation, resources, and support to guide development in these ways. It is not simply a matter of asking them to make lessons more entertaining.
A Different Way to Demonstrate Learning
There are existing educational models that take a broader approach to assessment.
The New York Performance Standards Consortium, for example, provides an alternative to relying on conventional state examinations as the central demonstration of readiness to graduate.
Immordino-Yang highlights the value of sustained, intellectually demanding projects in which students investigate a topic over an extended period. Such work can cross disciplinary boundaries and involve teachers, community experts, and other sources of guidance.
Students do more than submit a finished product. They present their work, respond to questions, explain decisions, and reflect on their learning process and possible next steps.
The resemblance to a graduate thesis is useful. A crucial part of the intellectual work is not merely answering a question someone else has supplied. It is noticing something worth understanding and developing a question that can be investigated systematically.
This makes room for both curiosity and accountability. Students still have to demonstrate knowledge and defend their reasoning. But the assessment also reveals how they formulate problems, use tools, interpret evidence, and respond to challenge.
The Goal Is the Development of the Person
The deepest shift is in what education is for.
If learning is treated as the endpoint, success can become a checklist of material acquired and answers reproduced. If learning is understood as a means of development, we ask a different question: How has this experience changed what the person is capable of becoming?
That does not diminish knowledge. It gives knowledge a larger purpose.
A strong education helps people use what they know to think more powerfully, engage other perspectives, question their own assumptions, and participate responsibly in the world. It develops not only the capacity to reach an answer, but also the judgment to recognize when an answer needs revisiting.
The same principle applies beyond school. Meaningful learning asks us to connect ideas with genuine curiosity, notice the stories shaping our reactions, and remain willing to reconstruct those stories when they no longer serve us or others well.
The starting point is not necessarily more equipment or another layer of testing. It is a different disposition toward learning, and a different goal for what learning makes possible.
Sponsor: LMNT
LMNT is a sugar-free electrolyte drink mix containing sodium, magnesium, and potassium. I use it in water in the morning and during exercise, particularly when I am sweating heavily. The sponsor offer includes a free sample pack with a purchase of LMNT drink mix.



