Deliberate cold exposure does not have to mean sitting in ice water for as long as you can tolerate. And heat exposure does not have to involve marathon sauna sessions. The more useful question is: How much temperature stress is enough to stimulate adaptation without overdoing it?
The answer starts with understanding what your body does when temperature changes. Cold receptors in the skin signal the nervous system, brown fat generates heat, muscles may begin to shiver, and blood vessels adjust to preserve core temperature. Repeated exposure can change how efficiently those systems respond.
My discussion with metabolic scientist Dr. Susanna Søberg centered on those mechanisms and their practical implications. Her research on winter swimmers provides an important reference point: brief cold immersions, combined with sauna, were associated with better insulin sensitivity and differences in thermoregulation. But the larger lesson is not to chase a particular temperature or endure more discomfort. It is to use manageable changes in temperature as a physiological stimulus.
Key Takeaways
- Cold activates thermoregulatory pathways that recruit brown fat and muscles to generate heat.
- Experienced winter swimmers combining cold and sauna showed better insulin sensitivity than matched controls.
- The weekly exposure totals are study reference points, not proven minimums or universal prescriptions.
- Mild cooling can activate brown fat, so extreme temperatures are not always necessary.
Table of Contents
- How Cold Is Cold Enough?
- Cold Plunges, Showers, and Cool Air Are Different Stimuli
- How Brown Fat Turns Cold Signals Into Heat
- Shivering and Afterdrop: Why You Can Feel Colder After Getting Out
- What Changes With Repeated Cold Exposure?
- You May Not Need Ice Water to Activate Brown Fat
- What the Winter-Swimming and Sauna Study Found
- The 11-Minute Cold and 57-Minute Sauna Reference Points
- The Søberg Principle: End on Cold
- Inflammation: An Interesting Signal, Not a Disease-Prevention Guarantee
- Make Temperature Change the Focus, Not Extremes
- Sponsor: Temperature Control During Sleep
How Cold Is Cold Enough?
There is no single water temperature that produces the same response in everyone. Experience, adaptation, and the type of exposure all matter.
Søberg’s starting point is subjective but useful: the water should feel uncomfortably cold. It should register as a meaningful change, not simply a refreshing bath.
That initial response is often called cold shock. It involves activation of the sympathetic nervous system and the release of catecholamines, including norepinephrine, also called noradrenaline. Breathing may become faster, and someone new to cold water may experience an involuntary gasp.
Those breathing changes help describe the response, but they should not become a performance target. Difficulty controlling your breathing is not something to intensify by choosing colder water or staying longer.
With repeated exposure, the initial shock tends to diminish. You may become better able to regulate your breathing and feel less overwhelmed. That is adaptation, not evidence that the practice has stopped working.
The goal is a controlled challenge, not an endurance contest. As Søberg emphasized, you do not need extreme cold to stimulate the systems involved in temperature regulation.
Cold Plunges, Showers, and Cool Air Are Different Stimuli
Cold-water immersion, a cold shower, and a walk in cool air can all stimulate cold receptors. They are not equivalent exposures, however.
- Cold-water immersion: Exposes a large area of skin at once and produces a rapid, potent thermoregulatory response.
- Cold showers: Provide cold stimulation to the skin, but the amount of brown-fat activation and the metabolic effects are less well established than for some other cooling methods.
- Cool outdoor air: Can activate thermoregulatory pathways without requiring immersion.
- Cool sleeping environments: Can provide a milder, longer exposure that has been studied for its effects on brown fat and insulin sensitivity.
This distinction matters because a result obtained with one method should not automatically be assigned to another. A cold shower may be accessible and physiologically stimulating, but we cannot assume that a certain number of shower minutes reproduces a winter-swimming study.
At the same time, immersion is not the only option. If you are not ready for a cold plunge, that does not mean you have no way to engage your body’s temperature-regulating machinery.
How Brown Fat Turns Cold Signals Into Heat
Brown fat is a specialized tissue that uses energy to generate heat. Unlike white fat, which primarily stores energy, brown fat contains abundant mitochondria and participates in thermogenesis.
White fat is not inherently something to eliminate. We need energy storage. The concern is excess accumulation, including fat around internal organs. Brown fat plays a different role: it can take up glucose and fatty acids from the bloodstream to support heat production.
From skin receptors to the nervous system
When skin temperature falls, cold receptors send signals to temperature-regulating circuits, including those involving the hypothalamus. Sympathetic signaling then helps activate brown fat.
Norepinephrine is central to this response. Cold exposure also affects other stress-related signals, including adrenaline and cortisol, although those responses differ in magnitude and change with adaptation.
The system acts quickly because maintaining core temperature is essential. It does not wait until you are deeply cold to begin responding.
Brown fat and muscles work together
Brown fat is one source of heat. Skeletal muscle is another, particularly when shivering begins.
These systems also communicate. In our discussion, I raised succinate as one of the signals linking shivering muscle activity to brown-fat activation. The broader point is that muscle and brown fat are collaborating, rather than acting as isolated heating systems.
Søberg also discussed additional signaling routes and possible roles for brown fat in broader temperature regulation. Not every pathway is equally settled. The clearest practical point is that cold is a potent activator of brown-fat thermogenesis.
Shivering and Afterdrop: Why You Can Feel Colder After Getting Out
One of the most useful concepts in cold exposure is afterdrop: core temperature can continue falling after you leave the water.
During immersion, blood vessels near the body’s surface constrict. That helps conserve heat around the core and vital organs. After you get out and those vessels reopen, circulation through still-cold peripheral tissues can contribute to further cooling of the core.
That helps explain why shivering may begin, or become more noticeable, after a cold dip rather than during it.
Shivering is muscular work that generates heat. Søberg’s point was that a modest shivering response should not automatically be interpreted as something harmful. However, this is very different from deliberately pursuing hypothermia or extending exposure until you are profoundly cold.
The exercise analogy: hormesis
Søberg repeatedly compared cold and heat exposure with exercise. Each can impose a stress that, at an appropriate dose, stimulates adaptation.
This is the idea of hormesis: a manageable stress can prompt protective and adaptive responses. Heat-shock proteins, cold-related cellular responses, and changes in mitochondrial function are among the mechanisms discussed in this context.
The analogy has limits. Cold exposure does not replace the benefits of exercise. But it is a useful way to understand why some discomfort can be part of the stimulus, while more discomfort is not necessarily better.
What Changes With Repeated Cold Exposure?
Adaptation occurs at several levels, not just in how mentally prepared you feel before getting into the water.
- Brown-fat capacity: Repeated cold exposure can increase brown-fat activity and, in some studies, the amount of detectable active brown fat.
- Mitochondrial function: Adaptation can support the cellular machinery used to produce heat.
- Vascular responses: Changes in blood-vessel regulation help the body manage heat loss.
- Stress responses: The initial catecholamine and breathing responses can become less pronounced.
These adaptations help explain why an experienced winter swimmer may respond differently from someone trying cold water for the first time.
Søberg described earlier research following middle-aged adults across a winter-swimming season of roughly four to five months. Reported changes included lower blood pressure, lower heart rate, and improved insulin sensitivity.
Those findings are interesting, but they do not establish that brown fat explains every benefit. Brown fat was not measured in that particular study. That unanswered question was part of the motivation for her own research.
You May Not Need Ice Water to Activate Brown Fat
Several examples illustrate how sensitive the thermoregulatory system can be to relatively limited cooling.
A cold hand can produce a response
Søberg described an experiment in which participants placed a hand in water at about 4°C for four minutes. She measured cardiovascular responses and used infrared thermography to assess temperature changes over a superficial brown-fat region near the collarbones.
Within minutes, she could detect a temperature increase consistent with activation in that region.
This was a laboratory demonstration, not a recommendation to make hand immersion your daily protocol. Its value is conceptual: the entire body does not have to be submerged for cold signals to influence brown fat.
A cooler bedroom can also matter
Another study discussed in our conversation examined sequential months of sleeping at different room temperatures. Participants slept with clothing and bedding, rather than lying uncovered in a cold room.
After a month at approximately 19°C, brown-fat activity and insulin sensitivity increased. Those adaptations diminished when the sleeping environment became warmer, first at 24°C and then at 27°C.
The NIH summary of this cool-bedroom research provides additional context on the study and its findings.
I asked whether exposed facial skin might help explain the response despite participants being under bedding. Søberg considered that plausible because the face contains many cold receptors, but it remains an interpretation rather than a mechanism established by that experiment.
The important lesson is that mild cooling can be biologically meaningful. Ice is not a prerequisite for every brown-fat response.
What the Winter-Swimming and Sauna Study Found
Søberg wanted to study a practice that people could realistically sustain, rather than an extreme laboratory challenge. She recruited experienced winter swimmers who had been participating for two to three seasons and compared them with a matched control group.
The swimmers combined brief cold-water immersions with sauna. A typical visit involved:
- A cold dip lasting about one to two minutes.
- A sauna session lasting about 10 to 15 minutes.
- A second brief cold dip.
- A second sauna session.
- A final cold dip.
They generally visited two or three times per week. The sauna was around 80°C. Because swimming occurred outdoors, water temperature varied seasonally, from approximately 15°C down to roughly 2°C to 4°C during the coldest periods.
Søberg described the shift many swimmers experience from an intense initial response toward a calmer state. Cold immersion can engage both sympathetic activation and parasympathetic responses associated with immersion and the diving response. The timing varies, so this should not be treated as a precise countdown that applies to everyone.
She also described feeling energized and more positive after her own first experience. That subjective response helps explain the practice’s appeal, but it is separate from the metabolic measurements.
Lower insulin with better glucose clearance
The study included cooling days and a thermally comfortable day. Participants arrived after fasting for eight hours, and measurements were taken while they rested rather than exercised.
Compared with controls, the winter swimmers produced less insulin during the experimental measurements. They also cleared glucose more effectively after a glucose drink.
That combination is important. Insulin helps regulate blood glucose; needing less insulin while clearing glucose effectively is consistent with better insulin sensitivity.
The winter swimmers also showed differences in temperature regulation, including warmer skin under some resting conditions and a greater thermogenic response to cooling.
These were comparisons involving people already accustomed to winter swimming and sauna. They do not prove that a new participant will achieve the same results by following the same schedule. Because cold and sauna were combined, the study also cannot cleanly assign every finding to one or the other.
The 11-Minute Cold and 57-Minute Sauna Reference Points
When Søberg totaled the participants’ exposure, their practice averaged approximately:
- 11 minutes of cold-water exposure per week, accumulated across short dips.
- 57 minutes of sauna per week, accumulated across sessions.
- Two or three visits per week, rather than one prolonged exposure.
Those numbers are useful because they show how little total time was involved. The cold dips were generally one to two minutes; sauna bouts were about 10 to 15 minutes.
However, 11 and 57 minutes are reference points from the studied practice, not proven universal minimums or exact optimal doses. The research did not systematically compare every possible temperature, duration, and frequency.
The strongest practical message is that longer is not automatically better. You do not need a half-hour swim in winter water to imitate the pattern studied, and increasing exposure indefinitely does not make a hormetic stress more beneficial.
For someone with only two available days, Søberg considered repeated short dips, separated by time out of the water, a reasonable way to distribute exposure. That does not mean everyone needs to reach a weekly number regardless of their response.
The Søberg Principle: End on Cold
What I call the Søberg principle is straightforward: when alternating cold and heat for a thermogenic training goal, end with cold so the body has to generate its own heat afterward.
Returning immediately to the sauna supplies external warmth. Ending with cold leaves more of the rewarming task to brown fat and muscle.
In Søberg’s explanation, that extends the physiological work beyond the dip itself. Thermoregulatory and nervous-system activity can persist while the body is still recovering from cooling.
This is a proposed way to emphasize the metabolic stimulus, not proof that every benefit requires a cold finish. It is also not an instruction to remain dangerously cold or refuse needed warmth.
The underlying concept is more useful than a rigid ritual: temperature transitions provide a challenge, and recovery is part of the response.
Søberg suggested that people may notice improved warmth and cold tolerance after several exposures. Her study also found warmer skin in winter swimmers under some resting conditions. She proposed that altered skin circulation and heat loss could help maintain thermogenic demand, although those explanations should remain distinct from the observations themselves.
Inflammation: An Interesting Signal, Not a Disease-Prevention Guarantee
Søberg’s work also examined inflammatory signaling, including interleukin-6, or IL-6. She discussed its relationship with IL-10 and the possibility that temperature exposure could influence anti-inflammatory processes.
These signals require careful interpretation. IL-6 is not simply a marker that is always harmful or always beneficial. Its meaning depends on context, and a change in one cytokine does not by itself establish a lasting reduction in inflammation.
The broader research question is important because chronic inflammation is associated with metabolic disease and has also been linked with depression, anxiety, and neurodegenerative disease. But those associations do not establish that cold plunges or sauna prevent or treat those conditions.
Likewise, the idea that modern temperature-controlled environments reduce opportunities for thermoregulatory adaptation is a useful hypothesis, not a complete explanation for obesity or chronic disease.
The appropriate conclusion is that cold and heat exposure are promising tools for studying physiological resilience. Their effects on disease risk require more direct evidence.
Make Temperature Change the Focus, Not Extremes
The theme that kept emerging throughout our discussion was flexibility. We do not yet have evidence identifying one perfect water temperature, one exact exposure duration, or one schedule that works best for everyone.
A practical interpretation of the research is to:
- Choose a manageable cold stimulus rather than assuming colder is better.
- Distinguish immersion, showers, cool air, and cool sleeping environments instead of treating them as interchangeable.
- Favor brief, repeatable exposures over attempts to endure extreme durations.
- Use the weekly study totals as context, not quotas.
- Understand afterdrop and treat rewarming as part of the experience.
- Recognize that adaptation can reduce the initial shock without eliminating the physiological response.
Cold shock, afterdrop, and excessive heat are real physiological stresses. Discomfort alone is not a sufficient guide to safety, and a research protocol is not an individualized medical recommendation.
The most useful shift is away from “How much cold can I tolerate?” and toward “What manageable temperature challenge can I recover from and repeat?” That is much closer to training than testing your limits.
For additional study references and discussion resources, see the episode show notes on cold and heat exposure.
Sponsor: Temperature Control During Sleep
Eight Sleep makes mattress covers with cooling, heating, and sleep-tracking capabilities that adjust bed temperature through the night. I have used an Eight Sleep cover for nearly five years. The offer shared for its Pod 6 system was up to $200 off through the sponsor link.



