Demo site generated by Convella. Not affiliated with Andrew Huberman. Just big fans :)

Overcome Addictions and Obsessions of All Kinds: Dopamine, Control, and Radical Surrender

Andrew Huberman
Andrew Huberman
Nov 9, 2026 • 19 min read

Addiction is not always about pursuing a stronger high. In its most severe forms, it can become a pursuit of something more fundamental: the ability to control how we feel.

A substance, a gambling app, a pornography habit, or an endless stream of digital content can create a small, predictable world inside an increasingly unmanageable life. Press the lever, change the feeling. Even when the pleasure fades and the consequences accumulate, the lever remains compelling.

That is one of the most important ideas from my conversation with Dr. Anna Lembke. Understanding dopamine helps explain how compulsive behaviors take hold. Understanding our relationship to control helps explain why stopping can be so difficult, and why recovery often requires more than abstinence.

The goal is not to eliminate pleasure, ambition, or agency. It is to restore the ability to participate in life without constantly trying to engineer every internal state and external outcome.

Key Takeaways

  • Addiction involves compulsive use despite harm, not simply frequent engagement in a rewarding activity.
  • Recovery requires restoring reward-system stability without replacing one compulsive pattern with another.
  • Surrender means releasing ineffective control strategies while taking responsibility for the next useful action.
  • Codependency can turn another person’s behavior into the main regulator of our emotional state.

Table of Contents

What Counts as Addiction?

Lembke defines addiction broadly as continued, compulsive use of a substance or behavior despite harm to oneself or others. Sometimes the person recognizes the harm. Sometimes family members, friends, or colleagues recognize it first.

Clinicians look for four central features, often called the four C’s:

  • Loss of control: Using more, or for longer, than intended.
  • Compulsion: Repeatedly returning to a behavior despite efforts to stop.
  • Craving: Experiencing a powerful urge to use or engage.
  • Consequences: Continuing despite meaningful harm.

Tolerance and withdrawal provide additional clues. Tolerance means needing more of a substance or a more potent experience to produce the same effect. Withdrawal means experiencing a painful response when cutting back or stopping.

This framework matters because addiction is not defined simply by how often someone does something. Exercise, work, sex, and digital communication can be healthy parts of life. The question is whether the relationship has become compulsive, difficult to interrupt, and harmful.

Why digital addiction is a collective problem

Lembke reports that roughly half the referrals to her adolescent clinic now involve some form of digital media addiction. That is an observation from her clinical setting, not a population-wide estimate, but it illustrates the scale of the concern.

Digital media presents a particular challenge because it is woven into work, friendships, education, and entertainment. Telling a child to put down a phone and play outside does not solve much if every other child is still online.

Her analogy is pollution. Individual choices matter, but individual choices alone cannot resolve an environment designed around constant exposure. Schools, governments, and the companies that build and profit from these technologies also have responsibilities.

Awareness has improved. The products, however, have often become more compulsively reinforcing. Recognizing the problem is an important beginning, not evidence that we have solved it.

How Dopamine Reinforces a Behavior

Dopamine is a neurotransmitter, a chemical messenger that helps regulate communication between neurons. It has multiple functions, but one of its central roles is in reward, motivation, and reinforcement.

Broadly speaking, the amount and speed of dopamine release in reward circuitry help determine how reinforcing an experience becomes. Dopamine operates alongside other systems, including endogenous opioids and cannabinoids. It is not a complete explanation of pleasure on its own.

Lembke uses rodent research to illustrate the range. In the experiments she describes, chocolate increased dopamine measures by roughly 55% above baseline, sex by about 100%, nicotine by about 150%, and methamphetamine by approximately 1,000%.

Those figures are not precise human conversion factors. Measuring dopamine directly in a rodent’s nucleus accumbens is very different from measuring it in a human brain. The useful principle is the scaling: different substances and behaviors can engage a common reward pathway with very different intensity and speed.

Gambling, sexual behavior, social media, alcohol, and other drugs can all recruit overlapping reward circuitry. Their effects are not identical, but the shared biology helps explain why compulsive patterns can develop around both substances and behaviors. The National Institute on Drug Abuse provides additional background on drugs, dopamine, and the brain.

The Pleasure-Pain Balance: Why More Eventually Feels Like Less

One of Lembke’s most useful teaching models is a balance with pleasure on one side and pain on the other.

At rest, the balance represents homeostasis: a relatively stable operating state. A rewarding experience tips it toward pleasure. The brain then initiates compensatory processes that pull it back toward equilibrium.

She imagines those adaptations as little gremlins climbing onto the pain side. They do not necessarily disappear the instant balance is restored. They can remain long enough to produce a temporary shift toward discomfort: the comedown, the hangover, or the urge to have just one more.

If the person stops, the system has an opportunity to settle. If the person repeatedly consumes a highly reinforcing substance or behavior, those adaptations can become more persistent.

Eventually, the person may need the substance not to feel unusually good, but simply to feel normal. Without it, ordinary life can feel flat, uncomfortable, or unbearable.

Common withdrawal experiences across many addictions include:

  • Anxiety and irritability.
  • Difficulty sleeping.
  • Depressed mood.
  • Persistent craving.

This helps explain a difficult clinical reality: someone’s circumstances can improve after stopping while their brain still feels worse. Relationships may be recovering and responsibilities may be getting handled, yet the person remains in a reward-deficit state.

It also complicates the idea of self-medication. A substance may temporarily relieve anxiety or depression while simultaneously perpetuating withdrawal-related anxiety or depression. That does not mean every mental health symptom is caused by addiction. It means the direction of causality deserves careful examination.

Restoring balance takes time and sometimes medication

Lembke describes two broad ways to restore stability. One is sufficient time away from the addictive substance or behavior. Another is appropriate medication that stabilizes the system without repeatedly producing sharp cycles of intoxication and withdrawal.

Buprenorphine and methadone for opioid addiction are examples of the latter approach. Medication-supported recovery is not a failure to recover. It can be the treatment that makes recovery possible.

For many of the patients and substances Lembke discusses, the first 10 to 14 days of abstinence are particularly difficult. She reports that many begin feeling substantially better during weeks three and four, with roughly 80% reporting improvement in the clinical pattern she describes. These are not universal timelines or a promise that recovery is complete after a month.

An abstinence experiment is not a recommendation to stop every substance abruptly without medical guidance. Some withdrawal syndromes require medical supervision, and treatment should be tailored to the substance, severity, and person.

A 30-Day Experiment Is a Starting Point, Not the Whole Treatment

When someone seeks help, Lembke does not begin by issuing a blanket command to abstain. Treatment starts with a therapeutic relationship: understanding the person’s use, its consequences, their motivation to change, and their confidence that change is possible.

If someone has repeatedly tried to stop alone and cannot, the answer may be more support, not another unsupported attempt. Intensive outpatient care or residential treatment may be appropriate.

When a period of abstinence makes sense, she often frames it as a 30-day experiment. The person becomes a scientist in their own life, gathering information about sleep, mood, craving, relationships, and functioning.

Thirty days is long enough for many people to begin experiencing a change in reward-system function. It is also a more approachable commitment than deciding, at the outset, what the rest of one’s life must look like.

Do you have to give up every rewarding activity?

No. Recovery does not require eliminating healthy sources of reward. Sleep, exercise, work, and social connection remain important.

The concern is replacement: removing one compulsive behavior while escalating another. Someone might stop nicotine but substantially increase alcohol, cannabis, gambling, or pornography use. That can preserve the underlying pattern rather than change it.

At the same time, Lembke sees meaningful improvement when people remove just one problematic substance without increasing anything else. Treatment can meet people where they are.

There are situations in which addressing multiple substances together makes sense:

  • The person wants to stop them together.
  • One substance reliably triggers another, such as coffee prompting cigarette cravings.
  • Evidence and the clinical situation support simultaneous treatment.

She points to research in people using both alcohol and tobacco in which those who stopped both had better longer-term outcomes than those who stopped alcohol but continued smoking.

The larger aspiration is not to become dependent on a more socially acceptable compulsion. It is to move out of the compulsive pattern itself.

Trauma, Genetics, Access, and the Limits of Insight

Childhood trauma is a significant risk factor for addiction. Abuse, neglect, and chaotic home environments can increase vulnerability to later mental and physical health problems.

Stress can also reactivate an established addiction. Lembke describes animal experiments in which drug-seeking behavior subsides after cocaine is no longer available, then returns after a severe stressor. The behavior has quieted, but the underlying vulnerability has not necessarily disappeared.

Trauma is not the only risk factor, however.

  • Genetics: A biological family history can increase risk even without growing up in a substance-using household.
  • Access: Greater availability creates more opportunities for use, reinforcement, and the brain changes associated with addiction.
  • Exposure: A stable family, good friendships, and a successful career do not make someone immune.

This is why finding the psychological origin of an addiction is not always the most useful first intervention. A person who is constantly intoxicated, withdrawing, or craving may have limited capacity to process trauma effectively.

Lembke emphasizes establishing early recovery and greater physiological stability so that deeper psychological work becomes more productive. Understanding what happened to someone matters. So does identifying what they can do differently now.

Responsibility here does not mean blame for being harmed. It means recovering agency over the behaviors that continue the problem.

Do people need to hit rock bottom?

Serious consequences often precede recovery, but there is no single required bottom.

One person’s turning point may be the expression on a loved one’s face. Another may continue through job loss, medical complications, financial ruin, or incarceration. The brain can be remarkably effective at minimizing consequences and explaining away their relationship to substance use.

A turning point occurs when those explanations stop working. The person can no longer maintain the belief that everything is manageable.

That does not mean families should wait passively for catastrophe. Lembke notes that skilled intervention professionals can help, particularly when families feel trapped and do not know how to change the situation.

The Addiction Beneath the Addiction: Control

Perhaps the most provocative idea in Lembke’s work is that, in severe addiction, the desired experience may no longer be pleasure. It may be control over a feeling state.

Humans evolved to predict what comes next and reduce uncertainty. We build mental models of the world, test them against experience, and adjust our behavior. These capacities are profoundly adaptive.

But an addictive behavior can shrink that process into a closed loop. Everything becomes organized around one dependable action: acquire, use, repeat.

The rest of life may be deteriorating, but inside that loop the person knows what to do.

Gambling offers a striking example. The compulsive gambler is not necessarily pursuing money alone. The game itself becomes the destination. Some describe losing as a justification to continue playing. Winning and leaving would end the little world in which their attention is completely absorbed.

The control paradox

Lembke distinguishes two modern mismatches:

  • The plenty paradox: Seeking pleasure and avoiding pain can become harmful in an environment of abundant, highly potent rewards.
  • The control paradox: Reducing uncertainty can become harmful when the pursuit of control expands far beyond what we can actually manage.

We can count steps, track sleep, monitor messages, optimize appearance, compare careers, and search endlessly for a better partner. None of those actions is automatically unhealthy. The problem begins when the practices intended to support life start replacing life.

A useful boundary is purpose. A good night’s sleep should help us participate more fully the next day. It is not merely preparation for earning another excellent sleep score.

Excessive control can also generate anxiety and shame. If the perfect life seems engineerable, every disappointment starts to feel like evidence of personal failure. Uncertainty becomes intolerable, and imperfection becomes an indictment.

At the other extreme, a highly managed life can become boring. We then seek manufactured uncertainty through feeds, betting, or games. The same person may crave control and crave escape from control.

What Radical Surrender Actually Means

Radical surrender is not abandoning responsibility or deciding that nothing matters. It is acknowledging that a familiar strategy is not working and becoming willing to stop imposing it.

In 12-step language, that can involve recognizing the limits of personal control, conceiving of a power greater than oneself, and becoming willing to accept guidance from that power.

For some people, that power is God. For others, it is nature, the cosmos, or a framework that places the individual within something larger. The essential shift is away from treating one’s own will as the only available source of strength.

I have seen the practical importance of that shift. A friend experienced repeated relapses, dangerous incidents, and multiple treatment attempts. A faith-based treatment experience followed by ongoing 12-step participation became a turning point. Years later, the change in his life and family remained striking.

That is an individual story, not proof that one pathway is right for everyone. Lembke, however, has encountered this pattern repeatedly: people who could not sustain recovery through their previous approaches sometimes change after a profound spiritual pivot.

Surrender is not giving the addiction permission to continue. It is giving up the belief that the same unsuccessful control strategy will eventually solve it.

The Neuroscience of Surrender: Promising Questions, Not a Finished Explanation

The neuroscience here is fascinating, but it is important to separate established anatomy from an emerging interpretation of spiritual experience.

The periaqueductal gray, or PAG, is a midbrain region involved in threat responses, pain modulation, and defensive behavior. Lembke describes research linking spirituality-related changes after brain lesions to a network whose connections include the PAG.

She also discusses experiments in which activity shifts from prefrontal regions toward the PAG as a threat becomes imminent. These findings raise interesting questions about the relationship between control, helplessness, and surrender. They do not establish a single spirituality center or prove a complete biological mechanism for recovery.

The PAG participates in systems involving endogenous opioids, oxytocin, and serotonin. Those systems provide plausible connections to pain relief, affiliation, and changes in how we respond to the world.

From repeating a strategy to reconsidering it

Lembke offers a broad contrast: dopamine can reinforce continuing a behavior, while serotonin-related processes may help support reevaluation and flexibility in particular contexts.

That is a conceptual model, not a universal rule that dopamine means persistence and serotonin means surrender. Both systems have many functions.

The larger idea is that addiction involves rigidly repeating a strategy despite mounting evidence that it is failing. A transformative experience may loosen that rigidity and make different action possible.

People sometimes describe such a shift as feeling more connected, less burdened, or newly receptive to their surroundings. The biological interpretation is that perception and learning may become less constrained by entrenched expectations.

None of this settles whether a higher power exists. Describing neural activity during prayer no more resolves that question than describing neural activity during vision settles everything about the external world. The neuroscience concerns the machinery through which an experience occurs.

Spirituality, Grief, and Problems We Cannot Solve

Lembke’s interest in surrender is also personal. After her son Lucas was diagnosed with leukemia and died, she pursued information, psychotherapy, and efforts to manage what came next.

Those approaches had limits. No amount of knowledge could explain the loss in a way that made it controllable. She describes eventually reaching a point at which she stopped trying to manage every aspect of the experience and began showing up for life as it unfolded.

For her, that change felt both spiritual and physiological.

This is an important distinction in mental health: some problems can be solved, while others must be endured, integrated, or grieved. Treatment and spiritual practice need not compete. Medication, psychotherapy, and faith can serve different, complementary functions.

Acceptance and commitment therapy offers a secular expression of related ideas: accepting what cannot be changed while acting according to values.

Spirituality is also not a measure of intelligence, and scientific curiosity need not exclude it. Both can involve humility about what we do not know. At the same time, religious language can be difficult for people with histories of coercion or religious trauma. There is no reason to insist that everyone use the same vocabulary or practice.

Facing mortality rather than organizing life around avoiding it

Our conversation also returned to death. Acknowledging that we are not fully in control includes acknowledging that our lives are finite.

Avoiding that reality may temporarily reduce discomfort, but it can also make the subject more frightening. Surrender involves turning toward what is true, including fear and sadness, rather than constantly trying to outrun those feelings.

The paradox is that accepting an uncomfortable reality can sometimes lessen the suffering produced by resisting it.

Codependency: When Another Person Becomes the Lever

Codependency extends the control problem into relationships. Instead of using a substance to regulate how we feel, we organize our emotional state around another person’s behavior.

If they are doing well, we can relax. If they drink, withdraw, struggle, or fail to respond as expected, we become dysregulated.

The term is closely associated with families affected by addiction and the development of support groups such as Al-Anon. But Lembke sees the pattern beyond the classic image of a partner covering for someone’s drinking.

It can appear in parenting, romantic relationships, and ordinary digital communication:

  • Needing a child to achieve in order to feel secure or successful.
  • Repeatedly seeking reassurance that a loved one is safe.
  • Monitoring someone’s location or messages to relieve anxiety.
  • Interpreting a delayed reply or a different emoji as evidence that something is wrong.

Technology promises reassurance through more information. Often, it creates more checking instead.

Lembke describes this in her own parenting: wanting a particular race result, grade, or response, then recognizing how easily concern becomes attachment to an outcome.

Helping is not the same as controlling

Letting go does not mean becoming indifferent. It means distinguishing between being available to help and trying to manage another person’s entire experience.

That distinction is especially difficult when a loved one has a severe addiction. Yet Lembke has seen family dynamics change when the person doing the monitoring and rescuing begins attending to their own recovery and stops participating in the same rigid pattern.

This can create room for the person with addiction to take responsibility. It does not guarantee that they will do so.

Useful supports include Al-Anon and Co-Dependents Anonymous. These groups provide ways to work on one’s own behavior rather than making emotional stability contingent on someone else’s choices.

Lembke observes some gender patterns in her clinical work, including mothers becoming more enmeshed and fathers withdrawing. She does not present population-level numbers, and those observations should not become rules about men and women. Both overinvolvement and detachment can leave a family stuck.

Recovery can also destabilize a family. When the identified “sick person” improves, other difficulties may become visible. That is another reason to think about recovery as a family-system issue rather than simply removing one person’s substance use.

Stop assuming you know what someone is thinking

One practical expression of surrender is giving up mind reading.

We often assume we know what a spouse, child, patient, or colleague means. Lembke notes that some of her biggest therapeutic mistakes occur when she assumes a patient’s internal experience resembles her own.

The alternative is straightforward, although not always easy: ask, listen, and allow the answer to be different from the story you had prepared.

Daily Practices for Tolerating Uncertainty

The aim is not to manufacture a crisis so that surrender becomes possible. It is to practice a less controlling relationship with everyday life.

1. Begin before the screen

Lembke starts her day with a brief prayer asking for help to show up well and do the next right thing. She then completes her morning routine before checking a device.

That routine usually includes exercise, breakfast, making the bed, brushing her teeth, and preparing for the day. Her reason is practical: once she enters the digital environment, her attention shifts onto a different wavelength.

2. Use devices intentionally

She tries to distinguish using technology as a tool from using it to alter her mood. Entertainment is not forbidden, but she wants to recognize when that is what she is seeking.

She also knows that moving video is particularly compelling for her, while reading and audio are less likely to become problematic. The relevant vulnerabilities differ between people.

3. Do the next right thing

Instead of trying to engineer a distant future, identify the action available now.

You may not know how a relationship, career, or recovery process will unfold. You may know that the garbage needs taking out, an apology is owed, or a responsibility needs attention.

This is agency at a workable scale. Good days become good weeks through repeated, values-based actions, not perfect foresight.

4. Practice being imperfect and unmeasured

Spend some time away from screens. Go outside without a device. Talk to someone without knowing where the interaction will lead. Do something you are bad at, perhaps something you will never become especially good at.

Lembke sees reasons for optimism in young people gathering to make music, crochet, and socialize without turning every activity into a performance or career opportunity.

I also find value in doing things with no intention of publishing them. A workout can simply be a workout. An experience can have time to develop meaning before it becomes content.

Sharing accomplishments is not inherently unhealthy. The point is to preserve some experiences that do not require an audience or a metric.

5. Ask for help without requiring certainty

Lembke recommends prayer even for people unsure what they believe. In her formulation, the starting point is acknowledging limits and asking for help beyond one’s own habitual thinking.

Faith, in this sense, does not require the absence of doubt. It can be a practice of humility and openness rather than a declaration of complete certainty.

She also discusses evidence that praying for others can shift the person praying toward more prosocial attitudes and behavior. That is different from demonstrating that prayer remotely changes another person’s medical outcome, a claim she does not make.

6. Let meaning be meaningful without making it causal

Grief often changes how people experience symbols, patterns, and nature. A bird, a cloud, or an unexpected coincidence may feel connected to a deceased loved one.

Lembke distinguishes taking comfort in a symbol from treating it as literal proof of causation. After Lucas died, she had distressing thoughts connecting his name with leukemia. She did not regard that association as a genuine explanation. Over time, she came to understand the experience differently, as a personal reminder to loosen her grip on control.

A symbol can offer comfort or guidance without becoming a scientific claim about why an event occurred.

Psychedelics, Ketamine, Stimulants, and GLP-1 Medications

Behavioral and spiritual approaches do not remove the need for careful medication research. Lembke is interested in new treatments while remaining attentive to what can happen when enthusiasm outruns evidence.

Psychedelics: meaningful potential, meaningful risk

Research on psilocybin has helped investigators explore altered self-experience, spiritual experiences, and plasticity. Some people report profound benefit.

I have described positive experiences with clinical psilocybin use involving therapy before, during, and afterward. That does not make it an easy experience or an appropriate intervention for everyone.

Lembke’s concerns come from treating people who have experienced misuse and harm. Responses can be unpredictable, and she discusses psychosis, severe mood disturbances, persistent perceptual symptoms, and other serious outcomes.

Her research has found increasing hallucinogen-related emergency department visits and hospitalizations as use increases. Rising numbers of harms do not, by themselves, establish comparative risk per use, but they do challenge the idea that broader availability is consequence-free.

The position is not that psychedelics should never be studied or used clinically. It is that benefit, risk, alternatives, and the treatment setting all matter.

Ketamine: supervision and addiction history matter

Ketamine is a dissociative anesthetic, not a classic psychedelic. Ketamine-based treatment has a role in depression care, but formulations and regulatory status differ. FDA-approved esketamine treatment should not be conflated with every form of ketamine prescribing; the FDA provides context on risks associated with compounded ketamine.

Lembke describes promising work combining supervised, in-clinic ketamine with psychotherapy for difficult-to-treat depression, including depression alongside alcohol use disorder. She emphasizes the need for more evidence.

She also treats people with severe ketamine addiction, including people whose previous ketamine problems were not identified before another provider prescribed it.

A legitimate diagnosis does not make someone immune to addiction to the medication used to treat it. That principle applies to opioids for pain, benzodiazepines for anxiety, and stimulants for ADHD as well.

Stimulants and poorly monitored prescribing

Lembke reports seeing more stimulant addiction associated with inadequately monitored online prescribing, particularly since the pandemic.

Telehealth itself is not the problem. The concern is prescribing without sufficient assessment, follow-up, and attention to whether medication is being taken as directed or has become compulsive.

GLP-1 medications and alcohol craving

GLP-1 medications represent a potentially important new direction. Lembke reports that some patients with severe alcohol addiction who had not benefited from other approaches entered recovery after receiving a GLP-1 medication.

One proposed mechanism involves reducing drug-related dopamine release in reward circuitry. Patients sometimes describe a formerly compelling food or drink as simply less interesting or less rewarding.

These are encouraging observations, not evidence that the medications work for everyone or that their role in addiction treatment is settled. A new mechanism is valuable partly because it may help people who did not respond to existing tools.

Can Thoughts Become Part of an Addiction?

Compulsive patterns do not always depend on an external substance or device.

Lembke describes patients with compulsive sexual behavior for whom fantasy was a central part of the reinforcing loop. Some could not sustain behavioral recovery until they addressed deliberate fantasizing as well.

Anticipatory cues can themselves become rewarding. In that sense, a thought can function both as a trigger and as part of the experience the person is seeking.

Negative states can also become self-reinforcing. Rage may provide an energizing, adrenalized state. Worry can feel like preparation or protection. Rumination can become familiar territory in which, at least, the person feels they are doing something.

Lembke describes recognizing this in her own worry: an uncomfortable state can still become the place one repeatedly returns to because it feels controlled.

There is overlap here with obsessive-compulsive processes, and these patterns should not all be treated as interchangeable diagnoses. The useful question is whether the loop helps us respond to reality or keeps us rehearsing the same internal experience.

Stepping away from that loop is another form of surrender: not solving every thought, not obeying every urge to rehearse, and becoming willing to return to the next concrete action.

Recovery Is More Than Removing the Drug

Abstinence can create the conditions for recovery. It does not automatically supply a meaningful life.

Lembke describes addiction as biological, psychological, social, and spiritual. Effective recovery may require work at all of those levels: stabilizing reward circuitry, addressing trauma and mental health, changing relationships, and developing a values-based way of living.

The common thread is flexibility. Can we recognize when a strategy has stopped working? Can we ask for help? Can we act responsibly without demanding certainty about the outcome?

Radical surrender does not eliminate effort. It redirects effort away from controlling the uncontrollable and toward participating honestly in the life that is actually here.

Lembke explores these ideas further in Radical Surrender, building on the reward-system framework of Dopamine Nation and examining how letting go can become a source of strength rather than defeat.

Share

Andrew Huberman

Neuroscience and science-based tools for sleep, focus, mental health, fitness and everyday well-being from Andrew Huberman and Huberman Lab.

© 2026 Andrew Huberman
Powered by Convella